Image used under license from Shutterstock.com.
The North American Soccer League (“NASL”) is accusing the U.S. Soccer Federation (“U.S. Soccer”) and Major League Soccer (“MLS”) of illegally conspiring with one another to ensure MLS maintains monopoly power as the only Division 1 (“D1”) league.[1] The parties headed to trial in Brooklyn federal court and the dispute lasted two week.[2]
NASL accused U.S. Soccer and MLS of violating Sections 1 and 2 of the Sherman Antitrust Act, of conspiring to restrain competition and of conspiring to monopolize markets, respectively, in Divisions 1 and 2 of men’s professional soccer leagues.[3]
The lawsuits date back to 2017 when the NASL sued U.S. Soccer over U.S. Soccer’s methods for assigning leagues’ divisional ranks and accused it of conspiring to control the professional soccer market.[4] NASL initially sought a preliminary injunction forcing U.S. Soccer to recognize NASL as a Division 2 (“D2”) league. [5] However, a district judge denied the motion and the case would continue for years after.[6] Ultimately, the case went to trial on January 13, 2025, several years after the initial suit, and named MLS as another defendant.[7]
U.S. Soccer is the governing body of professional soccer in the United States. But how does a governing body work in sports? Their role is essential in sports.[8] Governing bodies create and enforce rules and regulations with the intent to maintain the sport’s integrity, ensure fair play, and promote the sport’s progress.[9] Here, NASL accused U.S. Soccer of failing to uphold those very ideals.[10] U.S. Soccer maintains three divisions for professional soccer.[11] D1 includes MLS, and D2 includes the United Soccer League Championship (“USL”).[12]
NASL was formed in 2009 after several teams left the USL with the intention of creating a league to compete against MLS.[13] U.S. Soccer denied NASL the D1 status it sought and instead recognized NASL as a D2 league.[14] In 2018, U.S. Soccer denied NASL its D2 status, and NASL ceased operations.[15]
The key question here was whether U.S. Soccer unjustly denied NASL its desired status within the leagues.[16] Now, NASL contends U.S. Soccer and MLS worked together to keep NASL from joining the market.[17] On occasion, U.S. Soccer allowed MLS to keep its D1 status despite MLS failing to comply with the governing body’s requirements.[18] To illustrate, U.S. Soccer requires D1 teams’ home stadiums to have a seating capacity of no less than 15,000.[19] Even though not all MLS stadiums were compliant with this requirement, U.S. Soccer nonetheless granted MLS waivers while MLS’ new stadiums were under construction.[20] Meanwhile, in March of 2016, U.S. Soccer denied NASL entry to its D1 league, reasoning NASL failed to meet the stadium’s minimum 15,000-seat capacity requirements.[21]
Additionally, NASL asserted U.S. Soccer’s former president Sunil Gulati, who presided over the organization until 2018, also worked for an MLS team.[22] In this period of overlap, NASL claims Gulati made it harder to achieve D1 status and shielded MLS from competition.[23] Further, NASL highlights MLS’ ownership of Soccer United Marketing, the company responsible for licensing both U.S. Soccer and MLS’ bundled rights.[24]
Alternatively, U.S. Soccer argues its rules and regulations maintain thriving and stable soccer leagues.[25] MLS and U.S. Soccer also claim, “[NASL] never turned a profit, never had a broadcasting deal that paid it money, never signed a sponsorship agreement that generate[ed] any meaningful revenue and had a history frequent failures.”[26] Additionally, U.S. Soccer asserts its Board of Directors and MLS did not retain an agreement to block NASL’s success[27] and argues its directors are disinterested and fair.[28]
“Perhaps the most shameful part of NASL’s Complaint is the assertion that U.S. Soccer’s volunteer Board members have somehow been so “corrupted” by MLS that their actions as Board members form the basis for an antitrust conspiracy. The soccer community in the United States should be deeply offended by the suggestion that elected representatives . . . athletes . . . and independent directors such as Val Ackerman, Donna Shalala, and Lisa Carnoy, and others did not act in what they 7 believed was in the best interests of soccer when voting as Board members.”[29]
U.S. Soccer further contends that NASL’s failure is traceable to its connection to Aaron Davidson, a major backer of NASL who was involved in the 2015 FIFA bribery scandal.[30]
On January 30, 2025, the defendants filed a motion for judgment as a matter of law, stating, “NASL conceded that it has no direct evidence of any conspiracy” and failed to provide evidence of an unlawful deal that led to its fallout in 2018.[31] With $500 million in damages on the line,[32] the stakes are high for all parties involved.
On February 3, 2025, following a two-week trial, the jury came back with a verdict in favor of MLS and U.S. Soccer.[33] The parties won their case after asserting that competition and movement within the divisions did exist within the league.[34] Teams like Orlando City and USL had switched divisions.[35]
Nonetheless, the jury’s ruling remains a small setback for NASL as it remains undeterred from moving forward.[36] Jeffrey Kessler, NASL’s lead attorney, stated, “[w]e have great respect for the jury process, but there were some fundamental legal errors made which prevented the jurors from receiving important evidence or being instructed on the correct legal standards and claims. Our client accordingly expects to appeal.”[37] Unfortunately for NASL, the Second Circuit ruling in their favor won’t bring it back into existence.[38]
[1] Complaint at 67, N. Am. Soccer League LLC v. U.S. Soccer Fed’n, (E.D.N.Y. 2017, No. 1:17cv5495.
[2] Melanie Anzidei, NASL v MSL trial promises key insight into American Soccer, with $500m at stake, The New York Times: The Athletic (Jan. 17, 2025), https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/6068165/2025/01/17/nasl-mls-trial/?searchResultPosition=2.
[3] Amended Complaint at 66, 67, N. Am. Soccer League LLC v. U.S. Soccer Fed’n, (E.D.N.Y. 2020), No. 1:17cv5495.
[4] Daniel Kaplan, MLS, US Soccer face unprecedented scrutiny in NASL trial, Awful Announcing (Jan. 10, 2025), https://awfulannouncing.com/soccer/mls-us-soccer-face-unprecedented-scrutiny-in-nasl-trial.html.
[5] Michael McCann, U.S. SOCCER, MLS BRACE FOR AN ANTITRUST TRIAL IN NASL LAWSUIT, Sportico (June 15, 2024), https://www.sportico.com/law/analysis/2024/u-s-soccer-mls-nasl-antitrust-case-1234784239/.
[6] Id.
[7] Kaplan, supra note 4.
[8] What does a National Governing Body of Sport do?, Sport: 80 (Apr. 10, 2024),
[9] Id.
[10] Kaplan, supra note 4.
[11] Daniel Pena, Adult and Youth US Soccer Pyramid Explained, The Art of Football Blog (June 5, 2024), https://artoffootballblog.com/us-soccer-pyramid/#:~:text=At%20the%20top%20of%20the,Premier%20Soccer%20League%20(UPSL).
[12] Pena, supra note 11.
[13] McCann, supra note 6.
[14] Id.
[15] Id.
[16] Anzidei, supra note 2.
[17] Katie Arcieri, US Soccer Trial to Begin in Defunct League’s Monopoly Suit (1), Bloomberg Law (Jan. 13, 2025, 9:31AM PST), https://news.bloomberglaw.com/antitrust/us-soccer-trial-set-to-begin-on-defunct-leagues-monopoly-claims (last updated Jan. 13, 2025, 1:14PM PST).
[18] McCann, supra note 6.
[19] Id.
[20] Id.
[21] Arcieri, supra note 17.
[22] Jared Foretek, MLS US Soccer Seek Midtrial Win In $500M Antitrust Case, Law360 (Jan. 30, 2025 5:36PM EST), https://www.law360.com/articles/2290691/mls-us-soccer-seek-midtrial-win-in-500m-antitrust-case.
[23] Id.
[24] Id.
[25] Arcieri, supra note 17.
[26] Michael McCann, U.S. SOCCER, MLS AND NASL HEAD TO LONG-AWAITED ANTITRUST TRIAL, Sportico (Jan. 14, 2025, 5:55AM) https://www.sportico.com/law/analysis/2025/nasl-ussoccer-mls-trial-1234823696/.
[27] Id.
[28] Id.; see also A director is “disinterested” if they retain no interest on either side of a transaction or receive pecuniary benefit. See Andrew M. Johnston et. al., Special Committees of Independent Directors, Bloomberg Law, https://www.bloomberglaw.com/document/X2NCVI7C000000.
[29] Answer at 7, N. Am. Soccer League LLC v. U.S. Soccer Fed’n, (E.D.N.Y. 2020), No. 1:17cv5495.
[30] Anzidei, supra note 2.
[31] Foretek, supra note 22.
[32] McCann, supra note 26.
[33] Mike Scarcella, US Soccer defeats failed league’s antitrust lawsuit, Reuters (Feb. 3, 2025), https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/us-soccer-defeats-failed-leagues-antitrust-lawsuit-2025-02-03/.
[34] Jeff Carlisle, Jury sides with MLS, USSF in NASL anti-trust suit, ESPN (Feb. 3, 2025), https://www.espn.com/soccer/story/_/id/43680111/jury-sides-mls-ussf-nasl-suit.
[35] Id.
[36] Id.
[37] Id.
[38] Kaplan, supra note 4.

